Car dealer pushback heightens against automakers' demands for store improvements
Skip to main content
Sister Publication Links
  • Automotive News Canada
  • Automotive News Europe
  • Automotive News Mexico
  • Automotive News China
  • Automobilwoche
AN-LOGO-BLUE
Subscribe
  • Subscribe
  • Account
  • login
  • HOME
  • NEWS
    • Dealers
    • Automakers & Suppliers
    • News by Brand
    • Cars & Concepts
    • China
    • Shift
    • Mobility Report
    • Special Reports
    • Digital Edition Archive
    • This Week's Issue
    • Chinese, western consumers divided on electric, self-driving cars, survey finds
      Decline in ride hailing dents car sales, report says
      Nio launches another crossover
      Polestar
      Polestar 2 trial production begins at Geely plant
    • Four technologies that could take the world beyond lithium ion
      Many lessons learned -- and some underway -- on battery safety
      Leave room for lead?
      The 3 main types of lithium ion battery cells
    • Uber
      Uber reports 3,000 sexual assault claims last year in its safety review
      Toyota leads $50 million funding round for May Mobility
      Ford halts medical shuttle to test with AVs instead
      MB robotaxi web.jpg
      Daimler starts pilot testing of self-driving Mercedes taxis in the U.S.
    • Automotive News special report: Retail Realities
      2019 UAW-Detroit 3 negotiations: The path forward
      Dealerships owned by ex-NFL stars face collapse, litigation
      Want a luxury car? Try a Kia
    • Executives from some of the largest U.S. auto lenders debate the viability of 84-month car loans. From left, Ian Anderson of Westlake Financial Services, GM Financial’s Kyle Birch, Charles Bradley of Consumer Portfolio Services and Huntington Auto Finance’s Rich Porrello.
      Lenders differ on 84-month loans
      New to the U.S. landscape, a Mazda supplier commits large
      Kyle Shaules’ Civic rolled five times after he hit a puddle and hydroplaned.
      Honda shares crash survival stories
      Porsche aims to pair speedy Taycan with fast charging
    • Access F&I
    • Fixed Ops Journal
    • Marketing
    • Used Cars
    • Sales
    • Best Practices
    • Dealership Buy/Sell
    • NADA
    • NADA Show
    • Automakers
    • Manufacturing
    • Suppliers
    • Regulations & Safety
    • Executives
    • Leading Women Network
    • Guide to Economic Development
    • PACE Awards
    • Management Briefing Seminars
    • World Congress
    • Aston Martin
    • BMW
      • Mini
      • Rolls-Royce
    • Daimler
      • Mercedes Benz
      • Smart
    • Fiat Chrysler
      • Alfa Romeo
      • Chrysler
      • Dodge
      • Ferrari
      • Fiat
      • Jeep
      • Maserati
      • Ram
    • Ford
      • Lincoln
    • General Motors
      • Buick
      • Cadillac
      • Chevrolet
      • GMC
      • Holden
    • Honda
      • Acura
    • Hyundai
      • Genesis
      • Kia
    • Mazda
    • McLaren
    • Mitsubishi
    • Nissan
      • Infiniti
    • PSA
      • Citroen
      • Opel
      • Peugeot
    • Renault
    • Subaru
    • Suzuki
    • Tata
      • Jaguar
      • Land Rover
    • Tesla
    • Toyota
      • Lexus
    • Volkswagen
      • Audi
      • Bentley
      • Bugatti
      • Lamborghini
      • Porsche
      • Seat
      • Skoda
    • Volvo
    • (Discontinued Brands)
    • Auto Shows
      • Detroit Auto Show
      • New York Auto Show
      • Los Angeles Auto Show
      • Chicago Auto Show
      • Geneva Auto Show
      • Paris Auto Show
      • Frankfurt Auto Show
      • Toronto Auto Show
      • Tokyo Auto Show
      • Shanghai Auto Show
      • Beijing Auto Show
    • Future Product Pipeline
    • Photo Galleries
    • Car Cutaways
    • Design
  • OPINION
    • Blogs
    • Cartoons
    • Keith Crain
    • Automotive Views with Jason Stein
    • Columnists
    • China Commentary
    • Editorials
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Send us a Letter
    • Alfa-Romeo-Stelvio- web.jpg
      Alfa Romeo could be Tavares' toughest turnaround
      Iacobelli
      Alphons Iacobelli: The bad penny that keeps turning up
      With Mach-E, Ford ensures Mustang badge will live on
      Autonomous
      A call for clarity on self-driving terminology
    • view gallery
      1 photos
      Polarizing Design
      view gallery
      1 photos
      Charging Ahead
      Roger Penske buys the Indianapolis Motor Speedway and IndyCar
      view gallery
      1 photos
      Pace Truck
      FCA-PSA
      view gallery
      1 photos
      Merger Of Equals: Pt 2
    • Shifting gears away from the stick shift
      SEMA still a wonderful circus
      Penske still has plenty of races to win
      Ford's turn in the hot seat
    • December 6, 2019 | All Stars will leave an imprint on the industry’s future
      November 29, 2019 | Plenty to be thankful for in the automotive industry
      November 22, 2019 | GM’s lawsuit against FCA is all about payback
      November 15, 2019 | Will anyone buy EVs?
    • German car jobs boom comes to screeching halt
      John Pye
      AV testing needs clear NHTSA guidelines
      Hackett's remedy for sticker shock
      Amit Rosenzweig
      AV industry needs teleoperation laws
    • EV taxis
      Beijing, unrelenting, steps up push for EV output
      Buick in China
      Global automakers raise bet on gasoline crossovers, SUVs in search of growth opportunities
      American brands, losing ground, face new challenges in China
      PSA, FCA must confront excess China capacity under merger
    • Uber case should prompt tighter AV controls
      Plan to clean up UAW corruption is a good start
      Shared benefits make FCA-PSA union worth risk
      GM, UAW should get credit for working out deal
    • Trabant has been reliable, mostly
      Cadillac needs to get its priorities straight
      Dealers can find out how to follow ADA
      Indeed, Penske did have another win
  • DATA CENTER
  • VIDEO
    • AutoNews Now
    • First Shift
    • Special Video Reports
    • Weekend Drive
    • AutoNews Now: Uber discloses 3,000 claims of sexual assault in 2018
      AutoNews Now: UAW names Rory Gamble president
      AutoNews Now: UAW-FCA deal enhances profit sharing, health care
      AutoNews Now: PSA, FCA leaders discuss merger, friendship
    • First Shift: Tesla's China-made cars qualify for subsidies
      First Shift: LG Chem says it will build batteries with GM in Ohio
      First Shift: U.S. attorney wants 'more cooperation' from UAW in probe
      First Shift: VW faces more diesel litigation
    • Ford's Jim Hackett on Wall Street, the Mustang Mach-E and tech opportunities for dealers
      watch video
      9:13
      Women service staffers defy perceptions, boost customer satisfaction
      Tenn. dealer preaches profits, fixed ops longevity, workplace empathy
      Family, flexibility, fun crush employee turnover at No. 1 dealership
    • Why Carlos Tavares wants to merge PSA and FCA  
      Lincoln aims to 'paint a new picture' for shoppers
      VW's Scott Keogh on bringing 'cool' EVs to the masses
      How Toyota found its 'niche' in Mexico
  • EVENTS & AWARDS
    • Events
    • Awards
    • World Congress
    • Retail Forum: NADA
    • Canada Congress
    • Marketing 360: L.A.
    • Europe Congress
    • Retail Forum: Chicago
    • Leading Women Conference Detroit
    • Retail Forum: Toronto
    • Fixed Ops Journal Forum
    • 100 Leading Women
      • Submit a nomination for 2020
    • 40 Under 40 Retail
    • All-Stars
    • Best Dealership To Work For
    • PACE Awards
    • PACEpilot
    • Rising Stars
    • Europe Rising Stars
  • JOBS
  • +MORE
    • Leading Women Network
    • Podcasts
    • Webinars
    • Publishing Partners
    • Classifieds
    • People on the Move
    • Newsletters
    • Contact Us
    • Media Kit
    • RSS Feeds
    • Shift: A Podcast About Mobility
    • Special Reports Podcasts
    • Weekend Drive Podcasts
    • Ally: Do It Right
    • DealerSocket
    • Deloitte: Cyber everywhere: Preparing for automotive safety in the face of cyber threats
    • Facebook: The road to a zero-friction future
    • Guide To Economic Development
    • PayPal Credit: How consumer financing helps drive sales for online auto parts retailers
MENU
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. Dealers
January 28, 2019 12:00 AM

Dealers push back harder against mandates to upgrade stores

Hannah Lutz
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Print
    AUTOMOTIVE NEWS ILLUSTRATION

    Even as New England dealer David Rosenberg heeds automakers' requests for store renovations, he braces himself for business disruption and millions of dollars in expense that he often considers pointless.

    And he's not alone. While a dealership that attracts customers is important to retailers and automakers, some dealers and the brands they represent are at odds on whether automaker-mandated updates deliver any return on investment for the millions spent.

    For Rosenberg, who operates 58 stores, it's one thing to overhaul a tired dealership in need of repair or build a new store when the business has outgrown its old one.

    But a renovation at one of his already-nice luxury-brand dealerships won't "generate one more dollar" in revenue. And it will hurt business in the meantime.

    "It's actually going to cost me a lot of money," said Rosenberg, CEO of Prime Automotive Group. "Never mind the construction cost, but the disruption to our facility and to our employees and our customers is going to be enormous."

    Rosenberg: "It's actually going to cost me a lot of money."

    Rosenberg is among a group of dealers getting increasingly vocal about the costly store investments. While many states have legislated limits on the frequency of automaker-requested renovations, dealership improvement pressure continues to be a perennial headache.

    And the nature of retailer pushback has changed since the years immediately after the Great Recession. Then, dealers griped about pricey improvement mandates because many of them, still fragile from the dramatic plunge in auto sales in 2008-10, just couldn't afford it. Today, after years of sales near record highs, retailers are more likely to be on strong financial footing, but they just don't see the value of big dealership investments in a tight-margin market that's moving increasingly toward online transactions.

    It means dealers are more likely to negotiate the details and timing of the renovations with automakers. The pressure can trigger retailers to sell stores designated for renovation by the automakers — but it can also trip up the acquisition deals that result.

    Deal killers

    Upgrade limits
    These states have enacted limits on how often automakers can demand dealership updates.
    ■ Alabama   ■ Minnesota
    ■ Arkansas   ■ New Hampshire
    ■ Colorado   ■ New Mexico
    ■ Delaware   ■ New York
    ■ Florida   ■ Ohio
    ■ Hawaii   ■ Oregon
    ■ Illinois   ■ Pennsylvania
    ■ Indiana   ■ Rhode Island
    ■ Maine   ■ Texas
    ■ Maryland   ■ Utah
    ■ Michigan   ■ Virginia
    Source: Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers, Bass Sox Mercer

    Colorado dealer lawyer Stephen Dietrich, who works primarily on buy-sell transactions, said store improvement mandates are part of the negotiations for up to 40 percent of the acquisitions he works on. The mandates killed two of his deals last year. Beyond buy-sell deals, at least 70 percent of his clients are having conversations with automakers about store renovations, he said.

    While the frequency of automakers' requests has remained relatively consistent, "the stress on the problem is probably increasing because the other costs for a dealership are increasing, so that whole ROI conversation is becoming more highlighted," said Dietrich, a partner at Holland & Knight in Denver. Dealers are asking themselves: "Do I really want to commit and expend this capital for that purpose?"

    The answer is increasingly "no."

    The publicly traded dealership groups often cite costs of store improvements and their low return on investment as a reason for divesting dealerships, reports Kerrigan Advisors, a California buy-sell firm. Through the first nine months of 2018, the public retailers sold twice as many stores as they acquired — 48 vs. 24.

    Sonic Automotive said last year it sold several dealerships rather than revamp them. Penske Automotive Group CEO Roger Penske said last year the retailer would "look at what the capital expenditure requirements" by the automakers are, study the market and then "take our capital and be very strategic."

    In December, dealer adviser Alan Haig said in his third-quarter report on the dealership acquisition market that store improvement programs by Jaguar Land Rover and Lexus are drivers of potential buy-sell activity. Facility costs for Jaguar Land Rover dealerships are reaching into the tens of millions of dollars, a heavy investment for a low-volume franchise, Haig said.

    And Lexus' push for dealership improvements has led to more buy-sell transactions as dealers choose to "cash checks from buyers rather than write checks to contractors," Haig added in the report.

    Negotiating terms

    Dealers often negotiate with automakers when a request makes little sense because of property size, geography or other factors. They may propose completing the construction in two years, rather than one, for example.

    Some automakers are listening. Porsche's strict store guidelines have been a challenge for landlocked dealerships, said Robert DiStanislao, president of Porsche of the Main Line in suburban Philadelphia. But Porsche recognized the problem and has exempted dealerships that meet the previous-generation standards from having to update to the current one, said DiStanislao, a member of the Porsche Dealer Board of Regents.

    Colleran: Dealers willing to invest

    Mike Colleran, vice president of Infiniti Americas, said 92 percent of its dealerships have made the requested improvements.

    "We'd like to see all of our facilities be in our image, and we're mostly there," Colleran told Automotive News. "Especially in our larger metro stores, we see a great willingness to invest."

    In December, Lincoln postponed a program that called for dozens of dealers with dual Ford-Lincoln dealerships to invest in standalone stores after retailers expressed concerns. The brand had wanted those dealers to commit to the projects by July.

    "We just want to take some time to listen to all our partners," Greg Wood, Lincoln's sales and service manager, told Automotive News last month.

    In legislation introduced in California's State Assembly this month, automakers would have to limit their dealership improvement requests to once a decade.

    California is just the latest state to get involved. According to the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers, 22 states have passed seven- or 10-year limits on how often manufacturers can demand dealership updates. One state, New Hampshire, has a 15-year provision.

    In 2017, Mercedes said it intended to give its dealers a 10-year cushion on store renovations after dealerships complete the brand's second-generation Autohaus image standards. The rise of state laws setting limits was seen as a factor influencing the move.

    Worth the investment?

    Many store improvements pay off, some dealers acknowledge. More customers come in, and employees perform better, said Paul Walser, who oversees acquisitions and manufacturer relations for Walser Automotive Group, which has stores in Kansas and Minnesota.

    Rosenberg experienced that firsthand when he divided a dual Porsche-Audi dealership about two years ago at the behest of those brands. "We had outgrown it, admittedly, and we set records almost the first month going into the new facilities," he said. Prime is making about 50 percent more in net profit with the separate operations.

    But, Walser said, if automakers are "making changes on a frequent basis that don't really mean a lot, all that does is cause heartache." A request to swap out dark gray tile for light gray could cost $80,000, and "no customer would ever detect the difference."

    Rosenberg will soon renovate his Mercedes-Benz store at a cost of $3 million to meet the latest Autohaus standards, much to his chagrin.

    "By changing the blue poles to black and by building a glass facade … that's not going to bring me more customers," he said. "But Mercedes-Benz is a very valuable brand, and it's important for Mercedes-Benz to have an image that's consistent. And I get that."

    The project is less expensive than others Rosenberg has encountered. He says a dealership renovation can easily reach $8 million or more, not including real estate costs.

    Such costs, with no measurable return, are causing stress.

    Lutz: "We only have so much"

    "We only have so much money as retailers. It's a finite number," said Wes Lutz, outgoing National Automobile Dealers Association chairman and president of Extreme Dodge-Chrysler-Jeep-Ram in Jackson, Mich. "Everything we need to do is vying for that money. If you can't show me where it's going to sell more cars, I don't think it's fair to ask us to do it."

    It can be especially unfair to small dealerships, whether or not they spend for the improvements, Walser said.

    "If you're a guy in a small community and you're being asked to invest millions of dollars and your franchise potential is 30 units a month, the economics can kick you right out of the game," he said. "If you have a program that gives dealers that invest an economic advantage, the dealers that can't afford it find themselves in a situation where they can't compete with those that could because now they have a differentiation in terms of their cost."

    ‘Frictionless' system

    The investments also draw more scrutiny because, with pickup and delivery services and steps toward online transactions, customers have fewer reasons to spend time in a showroom, said Bob Tasca, president of Tasca Automotive Group in Cranston, R.I.

    "I'm just concerned that the future of our business is changing, and we have to pay attention to the change," Tasca said.

    A flashy new building may not help, given that evolution in how people are buying cars, lawyer Dietrich said.

    Moreno: Better uses for money

    Bernie Moreno, head of a luxury-brand dealership group in Ohio, says automakers should help dealerships create websites and technology to aid online sales instead of requesting expensive store renovations.

    "The expectation of the manufacturer is [that] I'm going to spend $500 to $1,000 for a website. But they want me to spend the equivalent of $800,000 to $900,000 a year for a facility. That's perverse," Moreno said this month at the KPMG Annual Automotive Executive Forum as part of the Detroit auto show.

    Moreno was recently at a dealer meeting for an automaker he wouldn't name, where executives were "proudly boasting" that their dealers were spending $80 million on facilities this year. Said Moreno: "Imagine instead if that person said we're going to spend together $80 million on retail automotive technology to make the system frictionless."

    Now that's a return on investment that more dealers might buy in to.

    Vince Bond Jr., Melissa Burden, Urvaksh Karkaria and Michael Martinez contributed to this report.

    TENSION BUILDS
    Letter
    to the
    Editor

    Send us a letter

    Have an opinion about this story? Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor, and we may publish it in print.

    Recommended for You
    Digital Edition
    THIS WEEK'S EDITION
    See our archive
    Fixed Ops Journal
    Fixed Ops Journal - 10-21-19
    Read the issue
    See our archive
    Sign up for free newsletters
    EMAIL ADDRESS

    Please enter a valid email address.

    Please enter your email address.

    Please select at least one newsletter to subscribe.

    You can unsubscribe at any time through links in these emails. For more information, see our Privacy Policy.

    Get Free Newsletters

    Sign up and get the best of Automotive News delivered straight to your email inbox, free of charge. Choose your news – we will deliver.

    Subscribe Now

    Get 24/7 access to in-depth, authoritative coverage of the auto industry from a global team of reporters and editors covering the news that’s vital to your business.

    Subscribe Now
    Connect With Us
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter

    Our mission

    The Automotive News mission is to be the primary source of industry news, data and understanding for the industry's decision-makers interested in North America.

    AN-LOGO-BLUE
    Contact Us

    1155 Gratiot Avenue
    Detroit, Michigan
    48207-2997

    (877) 812-1584

    Email us

    Automotive News
    ISSN 0005-1551 (print)
    ISSN 1557-7686 (online)

    Fixed Ops Journal
    ISSN 2576-1064 (print)
    ISSN 2576-1072 (online)

    Resources
    • About us
    • Contact Us
    • Media Kit
    • Subscribe
    • Manage your account
    • Reprints
    • Ad Choices Ad Choices
    • Sitemap
    Legal
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    Automotive News
    Copyright © 1996-2019. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • HOME
    • NEWS
      • Dealers
        • Access F&I
        • Fixed Ops Journal
        • Marketing
        • Used Cars
        • Sales
        • Best Practices
        • Dealership Buy/Sell
        • NADA
        • NADA Show
      • Automakers & Suppliers
        • Automakers
        • Manufacturing
        • Suppliers
        • Regulations & Safety
        • Executives
        • Leading Women Network
        • Guide to Economic Development
        • PACE Awards
        • Management Briefing Seminars
        • World Congress
      • News by Brand
        • Aston Martin
        • BMW
          • Mini
          • Rolls-Royce
        • Daimler
          • Mercedes Benz
          • Smart
        • Fiat Chrysler
          • Alfa Romeo
          • Chrysler
          • Dodge
          • Ferrari
          • Fiat
          • Jeep
          • Maserati
          • Ram
        • Ford
          • Lincoln
        • General Motors
          • Buick
          • Cadillac
          • Chevrolet
          • GMC
          • Holden
        • Honda
          • Acura
        • Hyundai
          • Genesis
          • Kia
        • Mazda
        • McLaren
        • Mitsubishi
        • Nissan
          • Infiniti
        • PSA
          • Citroen
          • Opel
          • Peugeot
        • Renault
        • Subaru
        • Suzuki
        • Tata
          • Jaguar
          • Land Rover
        • Tesla
        • Toyota
          • Lexus
        • Volkswagen
          • Audi
          • Bentley
          • Bugatti
          • Lamborghini
          • Porsche
          • Seat
          • Skoda
        • Volvo
        • (Discontinued Brands)
      • Cars & Concepts
        • Auto Shows
          • Detroit Auto Show
          • New York Auto Show
          • Los Angeles Auto Show
          • Chicago Auto Show
          • Geneva Auto Show
          • Paris Auto Show
          • Frankfurt Auto Show
          • Toronto Auto Show
          • Tokyo Auto Show
          • Shanghai Auto Show
          • Beijing Auto Show
        • Future Product Pipeline
        • Photo Galleries
        • Car Cutaways
        • Design
      • China
      • Shift
      • Mobility Report
      • Special Reports
      • Digital Edition Archive
      • This Week's Issue
    • OPINION
      • Blogs
      • Cartoons
      • Keith Crain
      • Automotive Views with Jason Stein
      • Columnists
      • China Commentary
      • Editorials
      • Letters to the Editor
      • Send us a Letter
    • DATA CENTER
    • VIDEO
      • AutoNews Now
      • First Shift
      • Special Video Reports
      • Weekend Drive
    • EVENTS & AWARDS
      • Events
        • World Congress
        • Retail Forum: NADA
        • Canada Congress
        • Marketing 360: L.A.
        • Europe Congress
        • Retail Forum: Chicago
        • Leading Women Conference Detroit
        • Retail Forum: Toronto
        • Fixed Ops Journal Forum
      • Awards
        • 100 Leading Women
          • Submit a nomination for 2020
        • 40 Under 40 Retail
        • All-Stars
        • Best Dealership To Work For
        • PACE Awards
        • PACEpilot
        • Rising Stars
        • Europe Rising Stars
    • JOBS
    • +MORE
      • Leading Women Network
      • Podcasts
        • Shift: A Podcast About Mobility
        • Special Reports Podcasts
        • Weekend Drive Podcasts
      • Webinars
      • Publishing Partners
        • Ally: Do It Right
        • DealerSocket
        • Deloitte: Cyber everywhere: Preparing for automotive safety in the face of cyber threats
        • Facebook: The road to a zero-friction future
        • Guide To Economic Development
        • PayPal Credit: How consumer financing helps drive sales for online auto parts retailers
      • Classifieds
      • People on the Move
      • Newsletters
      • Contact Us
      • Media Kit
      • RSS Feeds