General Motors again dominated the top rankings in customer satisfaction at dealership service departments, claiming three of the five highest-scored mainstream brands in a benchmark study released today by J.D. Power and Associates.
Buick held onto its highest-ranked mainstream brand title, while Jaguar soared to the top of the luxury category for the first time since 2008. Overall customer satisfaction slipped, but satisfaction for recall work jumped 12 points.
Buick was named top mass-market brand for the second straight year in Power’s U.S. Customer Service Index Study, scoring 836 on a 1,000-point scale. But Mini trailed closely behind, earning a score of 834. Volkswagen followed, and GMC and Chevrolet finished in the top five for the fifth consecutive year.
Recalls were considered repairs in Power’s study, Mike Battaglia, senior director of auto retail, said in an interview.
“Recall visits were up for GM brands, but despite that, [dealers] were able to actually manage that volume of recalls very well,” he said. “If they had not handled those well, the GM brands would have had a much more difficult time in CSI this year, but that was definitely not the case.”
Record year for recalls
GM, in the wake of its ignition-switch recall crisis, recalled an all-time record 26.9 million vehicles in the U.S. last year. As a whole, the industry recalled more than 60 million vehicles last year, nearly doubling the previous all-time record.
The study measured customer satisfaction with service at franchised dealership service centers for maintenance or repair work, a statement said.
J.D. Power fielded the study between November and December 2014, based on responses from more than 70,000 owners and lessees of 2010-14 model-year vehicles.
Jaguar topped the rankings in the luxury group with a score of 877, with Lexus, Audi, Lincoln and Cadillac completing the group of five highest scorers.
Jaguar moved to the top, from a sixth-place ranking in 2014, because of improvement in four out of five customer satisfaction measures: initiation, adviser, facility and quality, Battaglia said.
Overall satisfaction in both the luxury and mass-market categories decreased from a year earlier. The luxury brand average was 852 on a 1,000-point scale, a 3-point decline from 2014. In mass-market brands’ rankings, the average was 792, a 5-point dip from the year earlier.
But overall customer satisfaction among customers who took vehicles in for recall-related repairs improved to 789 on a 1,000-point scale, up from 777 a year earlier.
Satisfaction was 8 points higher for customers with a recall visit, compared to those with a repair visit, the statement said.
“Even though recalls can create a large influx of customers into the service department and really strain capacity, automakers are better prepared to handle recalls than they were a few years ago,” Chris Sutton, vice president, U.S. automotive retail practice at J.D. Power, said in the statement.
“Manufacturers have shown that it is possible to turn a potential negative into a positive when it comes to recalls if they’re done in a way that doesn’t inconvenience the customer,” he added.
Customers prefer dealerships that offer a no-appointment-necessary express lane, Power found. More than half of customers who used an express lane reported talking with a service adviser immediately, compared with 38 percent of customers who did not use an express lane.
Familiarity a plus
Familiarity also plays a role in customer satisfaction, the study found. More than 60 percent of customers said they had worked with the same service adviser in the past. Customers who worked with the same service adviser they worked with in the past were substantially more satisfied than those who worked with a new adviser.
Internet-based scheduling made a significant difference in customer satisfaction, Power said.