Storm clouds gather over dealer markups
Skip to main content
Sister Publication Links
  • Automotive News Canada
  • Automotive News Europe
  • Automotive News Mexico
  • Automotive News China
AN-LOGO-BLUE
Subscribe
  • Subscribe
  • Account
  • login
  • HOME
  • NEWS
    • Dealers
    • Automakers & Suppliers
    • News by Brand
    • Cars & Concepts
    • Shift
    • Mobility Report
    • Special Reports
    • Digital Edition Archive
    • Turn self-driving cars into offices? That'll take 30 years
      The bus stops here
      Last mile
      Self-driving cars might make people sick to their stomachs
    • Who wants VW's MEB architecture?
      GM will launch electric bike sales in Europe
      VW seeks to tap potentially lucrative ride-sharing market
      Apple stepped up AV testing to 80,000 miles in 2018
    • Dealerships owned by ex-NFL stars face collapse, litigation
      Want a luxury car? Try a Kia
      Costly lesson of tortuous legal battle: Get it in writing
      Denny Hecker: A changed man?
    • Access F&I
    • Fixed Ops Journal
    • Marketing
    • Used Cars
    • Sales
    • Best Practices
    • Dealership Buy/Sell
    • NADA
    • NADA Show
    • Automakers
    • Manufacturing
    • Suppliers
    • Regulations & Safety
    • Executives
    • Leading Woman Network
    • PACE Awards
    • CES
    • Management Briefing Seminars
    • World Congress
    • Aston Martin
    • BMW
      • Mini
      • Rolls Royce
    • Daimler
      • Mercedes Benz
      • Smart
    • Fiat Chrysler
      • Alfa Romeo
      • Chrysler
      • Dodge
      • Ferrari
      • Fiat
      • Jeep
      • Maserati
      • Ram
    • Ford
      • Lincoln
    • General Motors
      • Buick
      • Cadillac
      • Chevrolet
      • GMC
      • Holden
    • Honda
      • Acura
    • Hyundai
      • Genesis
      • Kia
    • Mazda
    • Mitsubishi
    • Nissan
      • Infiniti
    • PSA
      • Citroen
      • Opel
      • Peugeot
      • Vauxhall
    • Renault
    • Subaru
    • Suzuki
    • Tata
      • Jaguar
      • Land Rover
    • Tesla
    • Toyota
      • Lexus
    • Volkswagen
      • Audi
      • Bentley
      • Bugatti
      • Lamborghini
      • Porsche
      • Seat
      • Skoda
    • Volvo
    • (Discontinued Brands)
    • Auto Shows
      • Detroit Auto Show
      • New York Auto Show
      • Los Angeles Auto Show
      • Chicago Auto Show
      • Geneva Auto Show
      • Paris Auto Show
      • Frankfurt Auto Show
      • Toronto Auto Show
      • Tokyo Auto Show
      • Shanghai Auto Show
      • Beijing Auto Show
    • Future Product Pipeline
    • Photo Galleries
    • Car Cutaways
    • Design
  • OPINION
    • Blogs
    • Cartoons
    • Keith Crain
    • Automotive Views with Jason Stein
    • Columnists
    • Editorials
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Send us a Letter
    • Will Jaguar replace XE, XF sedans with a single EV?
      Could auto tariff threat be a turning point?
      Ram Chassis Cab goes high-tech
      Chevy's 2019 Blazer: More Camaro, less Equinox
    • Dealers need to be ready for anything
      EVs will come with economic cost
      Spend money on sales, not stores
      Put it on your bucket list
    • Elaine Chao: A speedier path for innovation
      Dealers' ads for service techs need major repairs to be effective
      Industry initiatives seek to ease tech shortage, but challenges remain
      Drivers for ride-hailing services can be a prime source of fixed ops profits
    • Let dealers invest in innovation, not renovations
      Hackett's vision for Ford is still a blur
      The last temptation of Elon Musk
      Path to trade deal didn't have to be so treacherous
    • Deeper issues in tech shortage
      Odds poor for Cadillac rebirth
      A boycott is not the answer
      Lincoln, Cadillac interiors need work
  • DATA CENTER
  • VIDEO
    • AutoNews Now
    • First Shift
    • Special Video Reports
    • Weekend Drive
  • EVENTS & AWARDS
    • Events
    • Awards
    • World Congress
    • Retail Forum: NADA
    • Canada Congress
    • Marketing 360: L.A.
    • Europe Congress
    • Fixed Ops Journal Forum
    • Retail Forum: Chicago
    • Leading Women Conference Detroit
    • 100 Leading Woman
    • 40 Under 40 Retail
    • All-Stars
    • Best Dealership To Work For
    • PACE Awards
    • Rising Stars
    • Europe Rising Stars
  • JOBS
  • +MORE
    • Webinars
    • Leading Women Network
    • Custom Features
    • Classifieds
    • People on the Move
    • Newsletters
    • Contact Us
    • Media Kit
    • Ally: Do It Right
    • Guide To Economic Development
MENU
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. ACCESS F&I
June 04, 2012 01:00 AM

Storm clouds gather over dealer markups

Will regulatory pressure force switch to flat fees?

Jim Henry
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Print
    Benoit: Why should dealers reveal markups?

    The dealer markup on indirect auto loans is the subject of intense debate among auto lenders, dealers, consumer advocates and government regulators.

    Some experts, including even some auto lenders, say a time may come when one-size-fits-all flat fees could replace the dealer markup, which can vary from customer to customer within certain limits, depending on what the market can bear.

    "The dealer markup model and the regulatory pressures we are facing, that's really my concern as you look at increased bank regulation. It's stuff we are all concerned about," says Andrew Stuart, CEO of VW Credit Inc.

    The markup model "can kind of be a target," he adds. Dealer markup, also called dealer reserve or finance reserve, is the practice whereby dealerships mark up the interest rates on loans they arrange for customers as a source of income for the dealership.

    The markup is a mainstay of a dealership's profits in the finance and insurance department and for the store as a whole.

    Most dealership groups don't disclose how much they make on dealer reserve. However, publicly traded Lithia Motors Inc. of Medford, Ore., reported its average was $406 per car in the fourth quarter of 2011, up from $361 in 2010. As of the first quarter of 2012, Lithia stopped reporting that specific number, although it still reports total F&I revenue per vehicle.

    In 2011, Lithia sold 44,537 new vehicles at retail, ranking it No. 9 on Automotive News' list of the top 125 dealership groups.

    Controversial practice

    VW Credit's Stuart is also chairman of the Vehicle Finance Division of the American Financial Services Association in Washington. At an association conference in San Francisco earlier this year, Stuart said he sees the auto lending industry slowly moving toward flat fees.

    The big question is whether government regulators, including the new Consumer Financial Protection Bureau or the Federal Trade Commission, could speed that up by taking another look at dealer markup. The practice has been controversial in the past.

    Potential interest from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau could also come as more consumers apply for loans online, instead of having a dealership F&I manager do it for them. That could lead to more direct-to-consumer loans, in which the dealership doesn't get paid for acting as a middleman.

    In addition, some shoppers -- especially younger ones -- distrust the dealership F&I process and want more transparency, research by Northwood University in Midland, Mich., shows.

    "At the dealership, there is no transparency,'' says Tom Alexander, Northwood's finance department chairman. "It's not transparent and never has been. The dealers don't want it to be, and that's not a good thing anymore."

    Past troubles

    Legally, the fact that the dealership can set the final interest rate on an auto loan is a big part of what made dealer markup controversial in the past. Dealer discretion raises the possibility that two customers with similar credit histories, representing similar levels of risk, can be charged two different rates.

    That's OK unless the price difference has what's called a disparate effect on customers. That is, a statistically disproportionate effect on a legally protected class of consumers -- for example, minorities. If that can be proved, it amounts to discrimination even if lenders or dealers didn't intend to discriminate.

    The disparate-effect argument was central to court cases in the late 1990s and early 2000s that led to settlements in which several auto lenders agreed to put caps on dealer markups.

    Michael Benoit, a partner with the law firm Hudson Cook in Hanover, Md., says he doesn't think the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau or the FTC is likely to tackle dealer markups directly. However, he wrote in an e-mail that it's possible regulators again could promote caps on dealer markups. Benoit is counsel for the AFSA Law Vehicle Finance Subcommittee.

    Benoit said dealers shouldn't have to disclose their markups on auto loans any more than retailers in other industries should have to disclose their markups.

    Warning shot?

    The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has been careful to avoid saying much about its plans to regulate auto lenders. But without singling out the auto industry, the bureau put out a statement in April that specifically said it intends to use disparate impact as a "legal avenue ... to pursue lenders whose practices discriminate against consumers."

    Tom Lazenby, senior vice president for Regions Financial in Birmingham, Ala., says that within reason, auto lenders would do whatever it takes to comply with the rules, but there is way too much uncertainty about what the rules will be. "Just give us a roadmap, and we will comply," he said, at the Auto Finance Risk Summit in Dallas last month.

    But what if lenders are forced to switch to flat fees?

    "I would take that deal," Lazenby said. "Just give us the road map."

    Letter
    to the
    Editor

    Send us a letter

    Have an opinion about this story? Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor, and we may publish it in print.

    Recommended for You
    Digital Edition
    THIS WEEK'S EDITION
    See our archive
    Fixed Ops Journal
    Thumbnail
    Read the issue
    See our archive
    Sign up for free newsletters
    EMAIL ADDRESS

    Please enter a valid email address.

    Please enter your email address.

    Please select at least one newsletter to subscribe.

    You can unsubscribe at any time through links in these emails. For more information, see our Privacy Policy.

    Get Free Newsletters

    Sign up and get the best of Automotive News delivered straight to your email inbox, free of charge. Choose your news – we will deliver.

    Subscribe Now

    Get access to in-depth, authoritative coverage of the auto industry from a global team of reporters and editors covering the news that's vital to your business.

    Subscribe
    Connect With Us
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter

    Our Mission

    The Automotive News mission is to be the primary source of industry news, data and understanding for the industry's decision-makers interested in North America.

    AN-LOGO-BLUE
    Contact Us

    1155 Gratiot Avenue
    Detroit, Michigan
    48207-2997

    (877) 812-1584

    Email us

    Resources
    • About us
    • Contact Us
    • Media Kit
    • Subscribe
    • Manage your account
    • Reprints
    • Ad Choices Ad Choices
    • Sitemap
    Legal
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    Copyright © 1996-2019. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • HOME
    • NEWS
      • Dealers
        • Access F&I
        • Fixed Ops Journal
        • Marketing
        • Used Cars
        • Sales
        • Best Practices
        • Dealership Buy/Sell
        • NADA
        • NADA Show
      • Automakers & Suppliers
        • Automakers
        • Manufacturing
        • Suppliers
        • Regulations & Safety
        • Executives
        • Leading Woman Network
        • PACE Awards
        • CES
        • Management Briefing Seminars
        • World Congress
      • News by Brand
        • Aston Martin
        • BMW
          • Mini
          • Rolls Royce
        • Daimler
          • Mercedes Benz
          • Smart
        • Fiat Chrysler
          • Alfa Romeo
          • Chrysler
          • Dodge
          • Ferrari
          • Fiat
          • Jeep
          • Maserati
          • Ram
        • Ford
          • Lincoln
        • General Motors
          • Buick
          • Cadillac
          • Chevrolet
          • GMC
          • Holden
        • Honda
          • Acura
        • Hyundai
          • Genesis
          • Kia
        • Mazda
        • Mitsubishi
        • Nissan
          • Infiniti
        • PSA
          • Citroen
          • Opel
          • Peugeot
          • Vauxhall
        • Renault
        • Subaru
        • Suzuki
        • Tata
          • Jaguar
          • Land Rover
        • Tesla
        • Toyota
          • Lexus
        • Volkswagen
          • Audi
          • Bentley
          • Bugatti
          • Lamborghini
          • Porsche
          • Seat
          • Skoda
        • Volvo
        • (Discontinued Brands)
      • Cars & Concepts
        • Auto Shows
          • Detroit Auto Show
          • New York Auto Show
          • Los Angeles Auto Show
          • Chicago Auto Show
          • Geneva Auto Show
          • Paris Auto Show
          • Frankfurt Auto Show
          • Toronto Auto Show
          • Tokyo Auto Show
          • Shanghai Auto Show
          • Beijing Auto Show
        • Future Product Pipeline
        • Photo Galleries
        • Car Cutaways
        • Design
      • Shift
      • Mobility Report
      • Special Reports
      • Digital Edition Archive
    • OPINION
      • Blogs
      • Cartoons
      • Keith Crain
      • Automotive Views with Jason Stein
      • Columnists
      • Editorials
      • Letters to the Editor
      • Send us a Letter
    • DATA CENTER
    • VIDEO
      • AutoNews Now
      • First Shift
      • Special Video Reports
      • Weekend Drive
    • EVENTS & AWARDS
      • Events
        • World Congress
        • Retail Forum: NADA
        • Canada Congress
        • Marketing 360: L.A.
        • Europe Congress
        • Fixed Ops Journal Forum
        • Retail Forum: Chicago
        • Leading Women Conference Detroit
      • Awards
        • 100 Leading Woman
        • 40 Under 40 Retail
        • All-Stars
        • Best Dealership To Work For
        • PACE Awards
        • Rising Stars
        • Europe Rising Stars
    • JOBS
    • +MORE
      • Webinars
      • Leading Women Network
      • Custom Features
        • Ally: Do It Right
        • Guide To Economic Development
      • Classifieds
      • People on the Move
      • Newsletters
      • Contact Us
      • Media Kit